Initiated By
FINRA
Allegations
NASD RULES 2110, 2310, INTERPRETIVE MATERIAL-1000-1 AND INTERPRETATIVE MATERIAL-2310-2: RESPONDENT ENGAGED IN UNSUITABLE AND EXCESSIVE TRADING IN THE ACCOUNTS OF CUSTOMERS, RESULTING IN SIGNIFICANT COMMISSION INCOME FOR HIM AND LOSSES FOR HIS CUSTOMERS. HE ALSO SENT A SERIES OF WRITTEN STATEMENTS TO CUSTOMERS WITHOUT PRIOR APPROVAL OF HIS MEMBER FIRM. THESE STATEMENTS WERE FALSE OR MISLEADING, IN THAT, AMONG OTHER THINGS, SUBSTANTIALLY OVERSTATED THE TRUE VALUE OF THE CUSTOMERS' ACCOUNTS AND/OR LISTED SECURITIES POSITIONS THAT IN FACT DID NOT EXIST. HE ALSO RECOMMENDED TO CUSTOMERS THE PURCHASE OF A SECURITY, WHICH WAS NOT SUITABLE FOR THE CUSTOMERS IN LIGHT OF THEIR INVESTMENT OBJECTIVES, RISK TOLERANCE, AGE AND INCOME. RESPONDENT WILLFULLY FAILED TO UPDATE HIS FORM U4 TO DISCLOSE SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT HE ENTERED INTO WITH ANOTHER MEMBER FIRM. HE FAILED TO AMEND HIS FORM U4 TO DISCLOSE SETTLEMENTS WITH CUSTOMERS.
Resolution
Order
Sanctions
Civil and Administrative Penalty(ies)/Fine(s)
Amount
$27,500.00
Sanctions
Monetary Penalty other than Fines
Amount
$8,711.25
Sanctions
Suspension
Registration Capacities Affected
ANY CAPACITY
Duration
ONE YEAR
Start Date
1/7/2013
End Date
1/6/2014
Regulator Statement
AMENDED HEARING PANEL DECISION RENDERED JANUARY 29, 2009 WHEREIN CODY WAS FOUND TO HAVE VIOLATED: NASD RULES 2110 AND 2310 BY RECOMMENDING QUANTITATIVELY AND QUALITATIVELY UNSUITABLE TRANSACTIONS IN CUSTOMER ACCOUNTS AND THEREFORE IS FINED $20,000 AND SUSPENDED FROM ASSOCIATION WITH ANY FINRA MEMBER IN ANY CAPACITY FOR THREE MONTHS; NASD RULE 2110 BY SENDING CUSTOMERS MISLEADING AND UNAPPROVED ACCOUNT SUMMARIES AND IS THEREFORE FINED $5,000; AND NASD RULE 2110 BY FAILING TO UPDATE HIS FORM U4 IN A TIMELY MANNER TO DISCLOSE SETTLEMENTS TO CUSTOMERS AND IS THEREFORE FINED $2,500. THE PANEL DID NOT FIND CODY'S FAILURE TO BE WILLFUL. IN ADDITION, CODY IS ORDERED TO PAY COSTS IN THE AMOUNT OF $7,087.50. THE CHARGE THAT CODY VIOLATED NASD RULE 2110 BY FAILING TO UPDATE HIS FORM U4 TO DISCLOSE A COMPROMISE WITH CREDITORS IS DISMISSED. ON FEBRUARY 23, 2009, FINRA'S DEPARTMENT OF ENFORCEMENT APPEALED THE DECISION TO THE NATIONAL ADJUDICATORY COUNCIL (NAC).
NAC DECISION RENDERED MAY 10, 2010 WHEREIN THE FINDINGS MADE ARE AFFIRMED AND THE SANCTIONS IMPOSED BY THE HEARING PANEL ARE MODIFIED; THEREFORE, CODY IS FINED $20,000 AND SUSPENDED FROM ASSOCIATION WITH ANY FINRA MEMBER IN ANY CAPACITY FOR ONE YEAR FOR THE SUITABILITY VIOLATIONS. FOR THE MISLEADING ACCOUNT SUMMARIES, HE IS FINED $5,000. FOR THE FORM U4 VIOLATIONS, HE IS FINED $2,500. THE NAC AFFIRMS THE REQUIREMENT THAT CODY PAY HEARING COSTS OF $7,087.50 AND IMPOSES APPEAL COSTS OF $1,623.75. ON JUNE 9, 2010, CODY APPEALED THE DECISION TO THE SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION (SEC). SEC DECISION RENDERED MAY 27, 2011 WHEREIN THE SEC ORDERED THAT THE DISCIPLINARY ACTION TAKEN AND COSTS IMPOSED BY FINRA ARE SUSTAINED. CODY FILED A MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION TO THE SEC ON JUNE 20, 2011. THE SEC DENIED THE MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION ON AUGUST 31, 2011. ON OCTOBER 25, 2011, CODY APPEALED TO THE U.S. COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FIRST CIRCUIT. ON SEPTEMBER 7, 2012, THE U.S COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FIRST CIRCUIT AFFIRMED THE SEC'S DECISION; THEREFORE CODY IS FINED A TOTAL OF $27,500, SUSPENDED FROM ASSOCIATION WITH ANY FINRA MEMBER IN ANY CAPACITY FOR ONE YEAR, AND MUST PAY HEARING COSTS OF $7,087.50 AND APPEAL COSTS OF $1,623.75. THE DECISION IS FINAL DECEMBER 7, 2012. THE SUSPENSION IS IN EFFECT JANUARY 7, 2013 THROUGH JANUARY 6, 2014. FINE AND COSTS PAID IN FULL 3/5/13.
Broker Comment
HEARING PANEL DECISION RENDERED JANUARY 29, 2009 WHEREIN RESPONDENT WAS FOUND TO HAVE VIOLATED: RULES 2110 AND 2310 BY RECOMMENDING QUANTITATIVELY AND QUALITATIVELY UNSUITABLE TRANSACTIONS IN CUSTOMER ACCOUNTS AND THEREFORE IS FINED $20,000 AND SUSPENDED FROM ASSOCIATION WITH ANY FINRA MEMBER IN ANY CAPACITY FOR THREE MONTHS; RULE 2110 BY SENDING CUSTOMERS MISLEADING AND UNAPPROVED ACCOUNT SUMMARIES AND IS THEREFORE FINED $5,000; AND RULE 2110 BY FAILING TO UPDATE HIS FORM U4 IN A TIMELY MANNER TO DISCLOSE SETTLEMENTS TO CUSTOMERS AND IS THEREFORE FINED $2,500. IN ADDITION, RESPONDENT IS ORDERED TO PAY COSTS IN THE AMOUNT OF $7,087.50. THE CHARGE THAT RESPONDENT VIOLATED RULE 2110 BY FAILING TO UPDATE HIS FORM U4 TO DISCLOSE A COMPROMISE WITH CREDITORS IS DISMISSED. FINRA APPEALED THIS DECISION ON FEBRUARY 23, 2009. NAC DECISION RENDERED MAY 10, 2010 WHEREIN THE FINDINGS MADE ARE AFFIRMED AND THE SANCTIONS IMPOSED BY THE HEARING PANEL ARE MODIFIED; THEREFORE, RESPONDENT IS FINED $20,000 AND SUSPENDED FROM ASSOCIATION WITH ANY FINRA MEMBER IN ANY CAPACITY FOR ONE YEAR FOR THE SUITABILITY VIOLATIONS. FOR THE MISLEADING ACCOUNT SUMMARIES, HE IS FINED $5,000. FOR THE FORM U4 VIOLATIONS, HE IS FINED $2,500. THE NAC AFFIRMS THE REQUIREMENT THAT CODY PAY HEARING COSTS OF $7,087.50 AND IMPOSES APPEAL COSTS OF $1,623.75. APPEALED TO THE SEC ON JUNE 9, 2010. SEC DECISION RENDERED MAY 27 2011 WHERIN THE SEC ORDERED THAT THE DISCIPLINARY ACTION TAKEN AND COSTS IMPOSED BY FINRA ARE SUSTAINED. IF NO FURTHER ACTION, DECISION IS FINAL JULY 26, 2011. CODY FILED A MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION TO THE SEC ON JUNE 20, 2011. THE SEC DENIED THE MOTION FOR RCONSIDERATION ON AUGUST 31, 2011. APPEALED TO THE US COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FIRST CIRCUT ON OCTOBER 25, 2011. ON SEPTEMBER 7, 2012 THE U S COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FIRST CIRCUIT AFFIRMED THE SEC'S DECISION: THEREFORE CODY IS FINED A TOTAL OF $27,500, SUSPENDED FROM ASSOCIATION WITH ANY FINRA MEMBER IN ANY CAPACITY FOR ONE YEAR, AND MUST PAY HEARING COSTS OF $7,087.50 AND APPEAL COSTS OF $1,623.75. IF NO FURTHER ACTION IS TAKEN, THE DECISION IS FINAL DECEMBER 7, 2012. THE SUSPENSION IS IN EFFECT JANUARY 7 2013 THROUGH JANUARY 6, 2014.